Tasting Notes
Eye: Dark amber maple syrup, though oddly a little lighter than the 10-year-old. Medium drooping rims and teardrops on thin legs.
Nose: Warm cinnamon coffee cake. Warm, warm, warm. The Jack profile is surprisingly understated here, present but not dominant. Some proof and oak, not distracting. Banana and caramel syrup flavoring freshly ground coffee. Remarkably balanced nose.
Palate: Peppery, spicy soy sauce and aged ponzu in oak, lots of Asian sauce vibes: savory and dark and sweet all at once. Berry cobbler with a slight char on the crumb. Mouthfeel is light on the tongue but deeply rich, hints of the Coy Hill and whatever Jack Daniel’s extract would taste like. Oddly less oak and less concentrated Jack flavor than the 10-year-old, maybe from a longer time at lower places in the warehouse. Caramel and spice more characteristic of a similarly-aged bourbon than Tennessee whiskey (let that one lie – don’t focus on the semantics).
Finish: Medium-length, nuttiness developing exponentially at the end. Warming al over with oily, creamy, and mouthfilling banana custard.
Overall: While the 10-year-old concentrated the Jack Daniel’s profile, the 12-year-old gives an entirely new dimension. Berry sweetness but not acidity, a slightly burnt crumb topping, and a slightly underdone banana bread. The umami and soy notes at the top are wild, and I had to double-check to make sure I wasn’t the only one getting them. If I have to go with only one bottle, I’m going with this one.